Updated April 02, 2020
COVID-19 & Privacy
History teaches us that moments of crisis are precisely when democratic values are most tested. Amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, S.T.O.P is continuing to fight to ensure civil rights are protected in a rapidly changing landscape.
From China to South Korea, Italy to Israel, efforts to curb the spread of the coronavirus are being used to justify an increase in surveillance. Longstanding privacy and civil-rights norms are in jeopardy across the globe. Unfortunately, we are already seeing the U.S. is no exception to this trend as both private and state surveillance tools are being rolled out rapidly in response to this emergency with little notification or oversight.
At S.T.O.P. we understand the impulse to use technology to prevent the spread of this virus, and encourage good-faith efforts to preserve public health. But we must remain vigilant to ensure those in power act in the public interest. We will be working throughout this crisis, helping guide difficult decisions on how to balance the need for both public health and personal privacy. That means critically evaluating the efficacy of monitoring and enforcement, and loudly advocating for the preservation of civil liberties.
As S.T.O.P. monitors developments and makes recommendations, we will post updates to this page.
Federal, State, and Local Emergency Response
Current legislation and executive actions we are monitoring concerning surveillance and enforcement responses to COVID-19:
New York State COVID-19 Technology SWAT Team
New York State released a call for “technology SWAT teams” to support New York’s COVID-19 response. To date, the state has provided no details on how SWAT Teams will be deployed, what data they will collect, and how New Yorkers’ information will be protected.
New York State Executive Emergency Powers Act (Senate Bill S7919)
The New York State Legislature quickly passed a bill expanding executive authority and providing discretionary funds to the governor to combat the spread of coronavirus in New York.Covid-19 Mobility Data Network
Federal, State, and Local governments are reportedly using a warrantless cellphone tracking program to monitor compliance with COVID-19 social distancing requirements. The program provides information on Americans’ movements in over 500 cities, providing data on apparent crowding to local officials, including police.
Legislation
Testimony
Reports
Op-Eds
NY Daily News - NYC’s COVID quarantine checkpoints are dangerous
Gotham Gazette - Surveillance and the City: Cuomo’s Covid Security Theater
The Daily Beast - Contact Tracing Might Become Cops’ Newest Surveillance Tool
OneZero - Covid-19 Can’t Be an Excuse for Back-to-School Surveillance
Gotham Gazette - Surveillance and the City: Public Trust Needed for a Public Tracing System
The Boston Globe - Tracking coronavirus with smartphones isn’t just a tech problem
Gotham Gazette - Surveillance and The City: A New York Dictatorship?
Fast Company - Tracking everyone’s whereabouts won’t stop COVID-19
The Daily Beast - Today’s COVID-19 Data Will be Tomorrow’s Tools of Oppression
NBC - COVID-19 tracking data and surveillance risks are more dangerous than their rewards
Gotham Gazette - Surveillance and the City: Cuomo’s Coronavirus Coup
Press Releases
S.T.O.P. Welcomes Introduction Of NY Geolocation Tracking Ban
S.T.O.P. Concerned By White House’s Reported Development of Coronavirus Surveillance System
S.T.O.P. Concerned By Proposed ‘Technology SWAT Teams’ For COVID-19
Sign-On Letters
Media
Washington Post - Tech to contain coronavirus on college campuses sparks fresh privacy concerns
CoinDesk - Citizen Apps’s New Contact Tracing Feature Raises Privacy Red Flags
Daily Dot - Experts call Republican coronavirus tracking bill ‘profoundly flawed’
WNYC - Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s role in contact tracing draws criticism
C|Net - Apple, Google to terminate COVID-19 tracking tools once pandemic ends
The Appeal - Government enforcement of quarantine raises concerns about increased surveillance
Daily Dot - Proposed White House coronavirus surveillance network faces immediate pushback
HuffPost - The Far-Right Helped Create The World’s Most Powerful Facial Recognition Technology
BBC - Coronavírus: governo brasileiro vai monitorar celulares para conter pandemia
The Intercept - Privacy experts say responsible coronavirus surveillance is possible
This Morning in Seoul - Digital surveillance during COVID-19 outbreak
Le Temps - La tentation d’une surveillance accrue à cause du virus
The Crime Report - Tech Experts in 35 Countries Launch War Against COIV-19 Cybercriminals
The Star - A software company touted by Trudeau uses phone data to map outbreak
Panorama Farmaceutico - Aumento de vigilancia por conta do coronavirus pode reduzir privacidade
Bloomberg - A Software Company Touted by Trudeau Uses Phone Data to Map Outbreak
Al Jazeera - Coronavirus: Tracking the Outbreak, or Spying on People?
Wall Street Journal - Coronavirus Rule Breakers Draw Public Ire Online
Daily Star - Coronavirus lockdown will create New World Order, bizarre conspiracy claims
Today World - As coronavirus surveillance escalates, personal privacy plummets
World Top Trends- Big News; Coronavirus Can Infect Privacy And Civil Liberties Forever
Press Stories - Fighting Coronavirus Abroad Raises Privacy Concerns
The Post - The Geiger Counter: The cure for coronavirus may be worse than the virus itself
New York Post - Combatting coronavirus abroad sparks privacy concerns
C|Net - Governments could track COVID-19 lockdowns through social media posts
TechZimo - How location data could play a role in managing the coronavirus crisis
NY Times - As Coronavirus Surveillance Escalates, Personal Privacy Plummets
Forbes - Coronavirus Could Infect Privacy And Civil Liberties Forever
Decrypt - Coronavirus surveillance may mean the end of personal privacy
Mothership - New York Times shocked S’pore’s coronavirus measures erode personal privacy
Index - Válsághelyzetben a legkönnyebb visszavágni a demokráciát
GritDaily - Privacy Concerns Surround Online COVID-19 Screening
C|Net - Google, other companies get your data if you use Verily's coronavirus site
Wall Street Journal - How China Slowed Coronavirus: Lockdowns, Surveillance, Enforcers
Pew Stateline - States Have ‘Immense’ Powers to Fight Coronavirus
NY Daily News - Lawmakers and legal experts call Cuomo coronavirus bill a power grab